Broads at 1812 Productions

Four years ago, 1812 Productions began their season with a comedy revue called “Broads.” It was a compilation of bits curated by their Producing Artistic Director, Jennifer Childs from the careers of women comics, from the 1920’s to the 1960’s.  The multi-talented Childs also added new material to the mix of jokes, routines, and songs. Now, they are bringing back that and am so glad that I have gotten a chance to see this uproarious review featuring many of the rebels of comedy from Mae West, Moms Mabley, and Sophie Tucker to other trailblazers who opened the doors for today’s comediennes.  

            The show is bold. It is naughty. It is bawdy. These are the women who didn’t play by the accepted standards of they day. These were women who were smart- no brilliant! They are BROADS and proud of it. They break the rules. They write and perform material that is often banned. Mae West spent eight days in jail for her show, “Sex,” after it had been panned by all the papers, yet sold out for a year and was frequented by society men and women.

            Much of their humor is about the man’s penis though the word is never mentioned. We learn of a song by Clara Smith about making a dead man come. Spinach is the metaphor used in the hilarious 1930’s song, “I Didn’t Like it the First Time.”

            There were so many one liners and fast jokes, the audience was in stitches. Yet though it was a revue, it flowed seamlessly as Melanye Finister, Rebecca Robbins, and Mary Elizabeth Scallen delivered the jokes and sang the songs without trying to imitate the old stars. Instead, they were just giving us the feel, the joy of extraordinary women. And they gave us something else, something important- they gave us the history.

            That may sound intimidating but it is not, thanks to the marvelous manner in which Childs has researched the backgrounds of the women and then, integrated it between jokes and songs that let me learn as I laughed.

            There was a vaudeville circuit for African-Americans who usually weren’t allowed to perform in white clubs. Bessie Smith and Ethel Waters got their starts there. Mae West wasn’t just a beautiful bawdy actress with a few famous lines that we all remember. She was a playwright and a screenwriter and she spoke out for gay rights back in the ‘20’s. Sophie Tucker joked and sang about how she didn’t need to look like Hollywood starlets- Nicknamed “The Last of the Red Hot Mamas,” she was happy with her heavy frame.

            I would be remiss if I didn’t mention Mark Randall, the onstage pianist who provided the music to accompany three talented and wonderful actors. The softness of his accompaniment was perfect.   

            And Jen Childs is simply amazing. She created a comedy theater 25 years ago and it as strong as ever! What a talent!! Thank you, Jen, for giving us “Broads.”  I loved every minute of the 75 minute show. You will too.

“Broads” at 1812 Productions     Plays and Players Theatre,  1714 Delancey Place, Philadelphia, PA 19103,   215-592-9560   1812productions.org     Thru February 26, 2023

Waiting For Lefty at Quintessence Theatre

“Waiting for Lefty” is a short play, consisting of seven scenes that revolve around a taxi driver’s strike that occurred in 1934. . Written a year later, playwright Clifford Odets has put together vignettes of the lives of those at that initial union meeting. Though the play is only an hour long, it is a powerful story of  families struggling to survive in the throes of the Depression. Sadly, the Quintessence production falls short in many ways.

            In 1935, with so many people starving or barely eking out a living, the Communist Party in America was trying to offer a viable alternative to what they saw as the wealthy elite living high off the backs of the workers.  And unionism was often associated with Communism.

We meet a woman, ready to leave her husband after their furniture has been repossessed for missing a payment, to return to an old boyfriend who is earning a decent living. We learn of another woman who will only keep her job is she spies on her boss. We see Irv who is telling his sister to leave the man she intends to marry because he doesn’t earn enough. We encounter Dr. Benjamin who is removed from the surgery he was to do on a woman in the charity ward because he has been replaced by an incompetent doctor who is related to a senator. (The woman dies, the hospital closes the charity ward, and the Jewish Dr. Benjamin is fired.)

At the union meeting, the union boss is still discouraging a strike. Is he connected to the racketeers that many feel are controlling the union? The drivers aren’t sure what to do. They are waiting for their trusted representative, Lefty to guide them.

It is obvious that he has the nickname, Lefty, because of his political affiliation., but no one ever mentions it. Others, who express sympathy for the poor, are just called Reds. It is a challenging time. But in spite of it all, I didn’t feel for the characters. They were either miscast, misdirected, or just not in touch with the people they are portraying.

In the first vignette at the meeting, many of the men were played by women who just didn’t pull it off. It was distracting. In the second vignette, the man was too young to be portraying a man who had fought in World War I, some 17 years earlier. But my biggest issue with most of the scenes was that characters were just talking fast and yelling. Their expressions of frustration were without  feeling, without angst. And worse, I missed about 20% of the dialogue in several scenes as the actors spit out their lines. I didn’t know what they were talking about.

Was it because I am just an old guy with hearing issues, I wondered? But at the end, I asked the three people sitting behind me if they had any issues hearing or understanding what was being said on the stage that is so very close. They each expressed the same problem I had, one saying “I didn’t know what was going on much of the time.”

When I got home, before I sat down to write the review, I called friends of mine who’d seen the show the night before. Same thing. I felt saddened by my inability to enjoy a play that was so important in its day. Perhaps, because it is early in the run, the situation will be corrected. I hope so.

“Waiting for Lefty” at Quintessence Theatre, 7137 Germantown Ave., Phila, PA 19119, 215-987-4450. http://www.quintessencetheatre.org  Thru February 12, 2023.

Cole For Your Stocking at Act II Playhouse

Act  II Playhouse had planned to do a musical review of the works of composer/songwriter  Cole Porter in the summer of 2020, but had to shelve the project due to covid. Rescheduled for a year later, it too, was cancelled. This time, they created the review, “Cole for your Stocking” as their Christmas show, even though Porter was not known for his Christmas songs. What they have put together is a simple, yet brilliant show featuring three singers and a pianist singing so many of Porter’s most famous songs.

            These three singers, Renee McFillin, Michael Indeglio, and Zachary Chiero are not just wonderful singers, they are also outstanding performers who enact scenarios around the songs Porter created for shows like “Kiss Me Kate” and “Anything Goes.” It’s just the piano player/musical director Dan Matarazzo and the three on a very simple set. It feels as though we are in the room with them as they sing “I Get a Kick Out of You, You’re the Top, Let’s Fall in Love, Just One of Those Things, All Through the Night,and Brush Up Your Shakespeare.” I didn’t realize how many of the songs I actually recalled and was singing along silently.

            Unlike the Gershwins or Rodgers and Hammerstein, who partnered, Porter was a an amazingly talented writer who composed the music AND wrote the lyrics. He started writing songs when he was 11 and continued writing until his health brought him down in the late 1950’s.

            I can’t describe the exhilarating feeling I had as I listened to the complex, yet very funny rhymes of the lyrics. The man was a creative genius. And he must have had so much  fun writing such wild and crazy songs. You will feel the fun as you sit and listen.

            To make it a Christmas tribute to Porter, there is one section where they take his songs, alter the lyrics in his unique style, and create a new Christmas version. Among those were “It’s Too Darn Cold”  and “Sleigh for Sale.” It is a riot!

            The singers, Chiero and Indeglio were so smooth as they presented Porter’s songs. The space at Act II Playhouse is so intimate, they sang to us without amplification. I can’t say enough about the strong but soft accompaniment of Matarazzo on the piano. So often, the musical accompaniment is so loud, it’s difficult to make out the lyrics. But Matarazzo’s gentle style would make it easy for even a younger person who was less familiar with Cole Porter to appreciate the man.

            Finally there is McFillin. What a gem! She sang with the power of Ethel Merman and  the sweetness of Judy Garland. Her expressive face reflected the various moods of the songs- from seduction to silliness. A beautiful woman, she resembled Marilyn Monroe and other sexy women of the 50’s. I was mesmerized by her look but even more dazzled by her powerful and beautiful voice.

            I am so glad that Act II Playhouse chose not to stream this show during the pandemic, but waited to give the live production it did. It is a winner!

“Cole For Your Stocking” at Act II Playhouse, 56, E. Butler Ave., Ambler, PA 19002, 215-654-0200, www.act2.org. Thru January 1, 2023.

Mary Poppins at Quintessence Theatre

Let me get right to the point. “Mary Poppins,” which is currently on the stage at Quintessence Theatre is a spectacular tour de force and a must see. I don’t usually begin a review like this, but when I went to see the show, I expected a variation of the movie that was full of familiar songs, but nothing like what I saw. The show is not based on the movie but derives from the London West End production that debuted in 2004 and is truer to the stories created by P.L Travers. Travers didn’t like what Walt Disney did to her characters but I’m sure, would have been proud to see the 2004 version and the Quintessence production. She died in 1996.

When I do think of Mary Poppins, I realize that almost 60 years after I saw the movie, I can still sing many of the songs. And those songs are in this show along with several others. But they have so much more depth than Julie Andrews and Dick Van Dyck gave them in the Disney movie. This is not to fault the actors, but to give credit to the manner in which Julian Fellowes wrote the book for the show, based on Travers’ characters.

For those who may not know the story, Mr. Banks (a banker) and his wife are looking for a nanny. He is not an easy man to work for, and nannies have come and gone. In flies Mary Poppins, with her umbrella, to take on the job.

After the first ten minutes, when we realize we are not going to see reincarnations of Andrews and Van Dyck, we become fascinated with this production of “Mary Poppins,” which spends time developing the many different characters‘ lives, that Mary touches. And Mary herself is a fascinating and fun character herself. She is stubborn. But she is also real. She has an edge. You wouldn’t dare put toads in her bed or pepper in her tea. Hanna Gaffney, who plays Mary, doesn’t try to put on a happy face every minute. But she does try to provide a lightness to the real problems faced by all the people in the Banks’ family. Oh yeah, she can sing. She can sing!!!

Bert, the chimney sweep, is another genuine person. Steve Pacek doesn’t try to play him as a man larger than life. And that is another feature of this amazing production- even when some of the characters are rather absurd, it has a depth that goes beyond the comical. 

And it doesn’t stop there. The remaining members of this ensemble cast take on many roles and each character portrayed is superb. Some have depth. Some are ridiculous. All move effortlessly through a simple set this is constantly moving. Also moving are the wonderful props, including the dog and of course, the kite. Director Emily Trask has put on the Quintessence stage a show that will long be remembered.

The show is 2 ½ hours, but it is totally engrossing and a show that everyone of all ages will love. And I’m sure you will be singing silently, the songs that you know while you watch and continue singing them after you leave.

“Mary Poppins” at Quintessence Theatre, 7137 Germantown Ave., Phila, PA 19119, 215-987-4450. http://www.quintessencetheatre.org  Thru December 31, 2022.

Eleanor at Act II Playhouse

Eleanor Roosevelt, wife of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, was First Lady of the United States for 12 years and redefined that office. She was an intelligent, dynamic, active woman who, because of her relationship with her husband,  helped shaped American politics and history. Act II Playhouse has brought to the stage Mark St. Germain’s one-woman show, “Eleanor” with Penelope Reed giving a strong performance in this 90 minute biopic, which is both a history of the times through Eleanor’s eyes, but also a look behind the scenes at her private life and the nature of the relationship between her and the President.

It begins in 1918, when Eleanor is unpacking the suitcase of Franklin and discovers,  in letters from Lucy Mercer, that her husband has been having an affair with Eleanor’s secretary. Divorce would end FDR’s political career, and Eleanor and Franklin are convinced by his domineering mother Sara and by advisor Louis Howe, to remain together. But Eleanor insists upon three things- that she can live her life as she sees fit, that they would have separate bedrooms, and most of all, that he would never see Lucy Mercer again.

FDR, who was Secretary of the Navy, then becomes the vice-presidential candidate in the losing 1920 election. A year later, he is stricken by polio, and can never walk again without assistance and crutches. Eleanor becomes indispensable. She becomes his eyes and ears and they hide his paralysis from the public.

The play is filled with the facts of the history of Roosevelt’s rise to the presidency and the presidency itself. In fact, it is a little top-heavy with history, though my friend, who saw it with me, said she learned a ton. I found the history to be little more than what one can get on Wikipedia. I, would have preferred  learning more about Eleanor herself. I was fascinated to learn that her mother died when Eleanor was 8. Her father, who she calls the real love of her life, died two years later. An alcoholic and probably a womanizer, he committed suicide. 

I wanted to know more- about her relationship with lesbian journalist, Lorena Hickok and with other women.  I wanted to understand Eleanor’s anti-semitism early in her life.  I wanted to know more about how she did connect to Franklin. When she tells us that she was not a very good mother and was distant from her children,  I wanted more information about what she was thinking that could take us beyond the legend that she was.

It is a challenge to condense a person’s life into 90 minutes. I’d seen the outstanding production that Act II did a few years ago with another one-woman show, “Becoming Dr. Ruth,” also written by St. Germain. In the end, the success of such a show depends on the actor. Penelope Reed is much more attractive than Eleanor. She is slimmer. She wasn’t given the famous “overbite” of the First Lady. She didn’t speak like Eleanor in voice or rhythm. But if I didn’t “know” Eleanor Roosevelt from newsreels and from when I did see her on tv when I was a child, I wouldn’t have cared. I felt the same way when David Oyelowo portrayed Martin Luther King Jr., in “Selma.” He was good, but he wasn’t King. Perhaps it is unfair of me to expect Reed, who gives a fine performance, to expect so much.

There is much to learn about Eleanor and the times she lived in Act II’s production. It is presented effectively. I had hoped for something more powerful, more emotional, more personal to enrich it more from playwright, St. Germain.

“Eleanor” at Act II Playhouse, 56, E. Butler Ave., Ambler, PA 19002, 215-654-0200, www.act2.org. Thru November 20, 2022.

The Glass Menagerie at Arden Theatre Company

            After writing plays for eight years, “The Glass Menagerie” was Tennessee Williams first successful play. Opening on Broadway in 1944, it won the New York drama Critics’ Circle Award the next year. Williams would go on to write “A Streetcar Named Desire, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Night of the Iguana,” and another two dozen major plays and along with Arthur Miller and Eugene O’Neill, is considered among the greatest American playwrights of the 20th century. But it was “Menagerie” that started it all. Arden Theatre, which already produced “Streetcar” and “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” has opened the 2022-23 season with “The Glass Menagerie.” It is a strong production, not falling into the over-the-top acting traps that made the film version in 1950 mediocre and by some critics, a failure..

            The Wingfield’s live in a small apartment in St. Louis. Their income comes from their son Tom, who works in a warehouse in a job he despises. His sister Laura is a cripple who is painfully shy. She fears that she will never attract a “gentleman caller,” that her mother wants for her. Their mother Amanda, on the other hand is constantly reminding them how beautiful she was and had 17 gentleman callers on a single evening. But we are also aware the her husband left the family, never return, many years ago. It is a very fractured family.

            Amanda escapes through her memories. Tom escapes by going out to movies, long into the night. But Laura cannot escape, and her mother convinces Tom to bring to dinner, a man, any man from work, who might remove the burden of her daughter and support them.

Amanda IS a force to be reckoned with. Whether her husband left because he couldn’t deal with her or that she became the way she is, because he left, we never find out. In trying to control their lives, she is constantly telling her adult children what they must do, just as Williams’ mother did. Krista Apple gives a fine performance in portraying Amanda as a real person and not a caricature.

Hanna Brannau is even more powerful as Laura. We feel her struggle in her attempts to move about, in her body posture, and in her anxious face. We understand her struggles without a word, and when she does speak, we listen and we care.

Tom Wingfield is not only a character, Amanda’s son- he is also the narrator, outside the play, observing the goings on with his mother, his sister, and with Jim, the gentleman caller in the second act. Sean Lally is superb portraying Tom- the alter ego of Williams, who grew up with a very troubled mother and fragile sister.

He recalls, then comments upon what they say- what he remembers. He even warns us at the beginning, that this is a memory play, so it might not be entirely accurate..

I did have two issues with the production. As it is a very naturalistic story, the characters often speak rapidly, they speak softly, and I missed several of their words. because on the Arden stage- in the ¾ round- they had their backs to me. Ironically, if this were a film with the camera poised in front of them, I suspect it would have been more powerful than the Hollywood production. But when I have to work that hard to hear, it makes me less engaged in the characters and their stories.

Finally, the set design was not effective. The Wingfields live in a small apartment in St. Louis. The large stage, with a minimal set did not seem to reflect their situation, despite a few props from the 30’s. The play would have been served better by a tighter space with more than just the table and chairs for the dinner and a small sofa. In tightening the space, it also would have brought the actors further downstage where it would have been easier to hear them.

Still, Arden’s production of is a good one. The disillusionment, the disappointment, and the struggles have been brought effectively to the stage by Director Terrence J.  Nolen.

“The Glass Menagerie” by Tennessee Williams, Thru November 6, 2022.   Arden Theatre, 40 N. 2nd Street, Philadelphia, PA 19106, ardentheatre.org  215-922-1122.

Travesties at Lantern Theater

The year is 1917. The place is Zurich, Switzerland. World War I is raging. Henry Carr, a British consular official is thinking about his time there when he encountered the communist revolutionary, Vladimir Lenin, the great modernist author, James Joyce, and Tristan Tzara, a founder and leader of the Dada movement, an anti-establishment artistic style that began that year.

Written and produced in England in 1974, “Travesties” won The Tony Award and the New York Drama Critics’ Circle Award for best play when it was produced on Broadway in 1975. Lantern Theater Company planned to run the play two years ago, but the covid pandemic prevented that. Now, they are presenting it as the opener of their 2022-2023  season.

            The play is a kind of a memoir by Carr as he recalls events as well as he can remember them from some 50 years before. As a result, there are often two or three renderings of the same event. It is not a historical representation of what happened, but a distracted story of how he sees Lenin, Tzara, and Joyce in Zurich. In fact, Carr did perform as Algernon in Joyce’s amateur production of Oscar Wilde’s “The Importance of Being Earnest.” Whether he ever met Lenin or Tzara is left for the audience to decide.

            Nevertheless, Carr’s memory is full of bravado. Of Lenin, he says “I knew him well.” Of Tzara, he tells us he is often asked about the man. Of Joyce, he recalls an absurd conversation full of comedic rhymes. He doesn’t think much of Lenin’s revolutionary spirit, of Tzara’s absurdist approach to art, or of Joyce’s writing. But in various retellings of the story, he compromises his own ideals in order to win the affection of the beautiful, Cecily.

            The stories of each of the men are fascinating. In a way, it is a history lesson for the audience. But that is also the most difficult thing about the play. It is almost three hours long with one intermission. Will today’s audiences sit through such a long play with so much exposition? To be honest, I found it challenging myself, particularly the lengthy first act- 90 minutes. Leonard C. Haas as Carr goes on and on and on. He talks fast and it is tedious and tiresome. He is talking at us, not to us and though the play is punctuated with many humorous, many clever lines, it needs to be delivered in a more realistic manner.

            Then, Tzara (Dave Johnson) enters and the tiresome monologue becomes a tiresome dialogue. As I listened, I could hear the brilliance of Stoppard’s words, but I wish more attention in this production was paid to the subtleties and insightful observations of the playwright. The heaviness of the play was finally lifted with the entrance of Joyce. Tony Lawton made James Joyce real for me. He had a naturalness that engaged me whenever he spoke. Lenin (Gregory Isaac) and his wife Nadya (Lee Minora) were also effective and real.

            The real treat of the play was Campbell O’Hare as Cecily. While she is the foil for Henry, she is much more. She is sharp-witted, edgy, funny, and also the target of Henry’s affections, but she has passions of her own. She is a delight to watch as her relationship with Henry is told again and again and again.. The cast is strong when they act as an ensemble, but Director Charles McMahon needs to get more from them  when they are lecturing each other and  “educating” the audience.

            If it was confusing at times, we know it was just as confusing for Henry, who says at the end, “I learned three things in Zurich during the war. I wrote them down. Firstly, you’re either a revolutionary or you’re not, and if you’re not you might as well be an artist as anything else. Secondly, if you can’t be an artist, you might as well be a revolutionary… I forget the third thing.”

            A postscript: Lantern Theater must be applauded for an amazing playbill. It is full of most interesting information, which if you can’t read it before the show, you must read it after.

“Travesties” at Lantern Theater Co., St. Stephen’s Theater, 10th & Ludlow Streets, Phila., PA 19107, 215-829-0395, www.lanterntheater.org Thru October 9, 2022.

Prisoner of Second Avenue at Act II Playhouse

Neil Simon is clearly the most popular American playwright in the last half of the 20th century. With a career that began writing comedy sketches for tv in the ‘50’s, he turned to playwriting and created over 30 plays that ran on Broadway and almost as many screenplays, usually from adaptations from his plays. Full of gags and one liners, the plays also had a social significance reflecting the times. One of those, “Prisoner of Second Avenue,” written in 1971, now graces the stage at Act II Playhouse in Ambler.

            Mel Edison, 47, has a successful job, a lovely New York apartment, two kids in college, and a loving supporting wife, when things fall apart. His home is no longer a haven- the toilet doesn’t work, the air conditioning overcools, the street noise is unbearable, and the neighbors are noisy. On top of that, he’s just been burglarized- he’s lost everything from his tv and his liquors to his suits. He becomes a prisoner in his own home. On top of that, he’s just lost his job. His becomes angry. He becomes paranoid, he becomes depressed. He has a nervous breakdown. But Simon’s play is not a depressing one. It is full of jokes and the audience is laughing constantly at Mel’s responses to everything.

            Director Tom Teti has assembled an outstanding cast led by Tony Braithwaite and Sabrina Profitt as the beleaguered man and his wife. They are the only two characters in the first act. But then, Mel’s siblings arrive in the second act to try some sort of intervention. Three sisters and a brother, and they are a riot. Zinger after zinger as they assess the situation. They care for their brother but also, try to figure out what they can and will do to assist, based on the cost of the treatment he may need.

            Twenty-two years later, Simon wrote a play, “Laughter on the 23rd Floor.” This one might easily have been called Laughter on the 14th Floor.” Still, underneath all that laughter is a seriousness that is always present and gives his plays the power that propels it beyond a simple sitcom mentality. There are constant audio reports of the crime wave that is sweeping New York.

 There are a few times when the depth is lost in the funny jokes. But that is Simon’s style and it is minor. If there is one adjustment to consider, I would tone down Mel’s volume a notch to let us see what is inside him a bit more. But Braithewaite is one of the finest actors around, so good that I didn’t even mind his not playing the show without a New York accent. He pulls off every role I’ve ever seen him perform. And with the rest of the ensemble, they do a wonderful job in bringing this Neil Simon classic to the stage.

“Prisoner of Second Avenue” at Act II Playhouse, 56, E. Butler Ave., Ambler, PA 19002, 215-654-0200, www.act2.org. Thru Sept. 25, 2022.

Together Off-Broadway: Merman & Martin at Act II Playhouse

Two Broadway legends, Ethel Merman and Mary Martin appeared together on television in 1953 to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Ford Motor Corporation. Rivals for the great roles, they became friends and traveled and performed together for years. In “Together Off-Broadway:  Merman & Martin, Act II Playhouse has put together a 70 minute show that is outstanding as we learn about these great stars while being thoroughly entertained by the songs they made famous.

            The act, was originated by Meredith Beck and Sarah J. Gafgen, the actors who play Martin and Merman, and they performed it around the greater Philadelphia area at various retirement homes. It was expanded into the current show by Act II’s Artistic Director Tony Braithwaite and Music Director Dan Matarazzo.

            Beck and Gafgen sing the songs of Cole Porter, Irving Berlin, and the Gershwins- the very songs they sang in the Broadway musicals- “My Heart Belongs to Daddy, Doin’ What Comes Naturally, I Can Do Anything Better than You, I’ve Got Rhythm.” I sat there realizing that I knew every song they sang, not from the theater, but from the LP’s. And these two performers were extraordinary!

            Gafgen didn’t just look like Merman, she had the power and the range of the singer. Ethel Merman was the original Rose in Sondheim and Styne’s show, “Gypsy. “Everything’s Coming Up Roses,” which she sings in it, became her signature song..

            Mary Martin, as Nellie Forbush in Rodgers and Hammerstein’s “South Pacific,” sang so many classics-“I’m Gonna Wash that Man Right Outa My Hair and “I’m in Love with a Wonderful Guy.” Beck nails all the Martin songs, including “Never Never Land” from “Peter Pan,” which Martin played on Broadway and twice on live tv in the ‘50’s.

            They each had a run playing Annie Oakley in “Annie Get Your Gun.” They entertain us as they sing “I Can Do Anything Better than You,” competing with each other.

            The show at Act II is more than song. We learn what Merman felt about her fourth and last husband Ernest Borgnine- the marriage lasted a few weeks. We learn how Marin had a child when she was just 17 years old- Larry Hagman. We see them waiting for the results of the 1960 Tony Awards where they were pitted against each other for “Best Actress in a Musial.” It is so much fun to watch them!

            And then we learn of all the movie roles that they didn’t get, roles which they created on Broadway. Betty Hutton played Annie Oakley. Rosiland Russell played Rose in “Gypsy,”  Julie Andrews played Maria von Trapp in “The Sound of Music,” the role originated by Martin on Broadway.

            On the stage with these two virtuosos is Dan Matarazzo, the pianist. He blends  seamlessly as he accompanies Beck and Gafgen, playing so softly at times, that we can easily hear the gentlest of songs without missing a word. And the costumes designed by Janus Stefanowicz were beautiful.

            Two more comments. I wonder what the response would be to younger audiences who don’t know the songs or know Ethel Merman and Mary Martin. In a way, it makes me sad that they don’t know these great women and the great songwriters, and I hope they come out to see the show.

            As for criticism, I only wish that the program had more information about the development of the show, about Merman and Martin, as well as a list of the songs they sang. But you don’t really need it if you just sit back and listen and be carted off to Broadway.

“Together Off-Broadway: Merman & Martin.” Created by Meredith Beck, Sarah J. Gafgen, Tony Braithwaite, and Dan Matarazzo.  Thru August 7, 2022. Act II Playhouse, 56 E. Butler Ave., Ambler, PA 19002.   act2.org   215-654-0200

Camille at Quintessence Theater

In 1848, 23-year old Alexandre Dumas fils wrote a semi-autobiographical novel about his love affair with a courtesan who was suffering with tuberculosis, then called consumption. Four years later, he turned “Camille”  into such a successful play opening in Paris.  Giuseppe Verdi put it to music the next year. Thus was born the famed opera, “La Traviata.”

            Lest I lead you in the wrong direction, the author of the play is not the well known  author of “The Three Musketeers,” Alexandre Dumas, but his illegitimate son. The word “fils” is attached to the son’s name- it is a translation from the French, meaning “son.”

            Quintessence Theatre has produced the original play on its intimate theater-in-the round space with a fine cast, led by Billie Wyatt as Camille. She fights her illness as she struggles with how to handle her life as she is pursued by two men. She doesn’t trust her judgment, but soon falls in love with Armand (Dax Richardson), while trying to fend off Count de Varville (Lee Thomas Cortopassi).

            There are other relationships we learn about through talk… and there’s plenty of talk. In fact, there’s very little action in the play and it is often difficult to absorb all that the ten characters are saying, particularly when he or she has their back to your side of the audience and they talk softly without mics. Though their stories are interesting, they go on and on. We can’t see the passion of the characters and it is not film, where the camera can move when the actors don’t. We do have the wonderful costumes designed by Anna Sorrentino to look at, fortunately. Director Steven Anthony Wright could have been more creative in the staging of the play with this talented group of actors. But slowly, very slowly, the story emerges.

            One theme of the play is jealousy. We watch the other two couples as they toy and tease each other. We see Armand’s jealousy of Varville. But the crisis comes when Armand’s father steps in and tries to convince Camille not to run off with his son, lest it wreak havoc for Armand’s sister, who would be shamed and unable to marry her fiancé.

            The play is 2 ½ hours long and in today’s theater world, that’s a long time to sit through conversation after conversation and many monologues. Perhaps it is just me. I haven’t even attempted to see a 2 ½ hour play by the great William Shakespeare in several years. After all, “Camille” is a major play in the history of theater. I am curious to see the musical that Verdi turned the play into and wonder  if it will hold my attention more. It was one of the most performed operas for well over a hundred years.

“Camille”  at Quintessence Theatre, 7137 Germantown Ave., Phila, PA 19119, 215-987-4450. http://www.quintessencetheatre.org  Thru July 3, 2022.

This review appeared late because I contracted Covid and was out of circulation.